Top risks and controls for Small Business Banking
The Small Business Banking register lists 26 key risks and 78 best-practice controls across 7 units: Business Development, Credit Analysis, Loan Processing and Underwriting, Relationship Management, Small Business Marketing, Small Business Support, Treasury Management. Use it to identify risks, benchmark your existing controls or start a risk and control self-assessment (RCSA).
A bank's small business banking division is crucial since it offers small business owners and entrepreneurs essential financial services.
Small business banking entails inherent risks that must be addressed to safeguard both the bank and its clients. This is true of any banking activity.
So, one of the most important steps in controlling these risks is to do risk assessments.
Risk assessments support banks in identifying potential threats and weaknesses, evaluating the likelihood and consequences of those risks, and creating mitigation plans.
Small business banking activities of a bank can aid in ensuring the security and safety of their operations as well as the financial stability of their clients by conducting frequent risk assessments.
Units covered
Business Development: key risks and controls
Accountable for growing the bank's small business portfolio and attracting new small company clients.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Difficulty in reaching the target market | Small business banking departments may struggle to effectively reach their target market due to limited marketing budgets or a lack of knowledge about how to effectively market to small business owners. |
|
| Increasing competition | The small business banking landscape has become increasingly competitive over the years, with new entrants and non-bank lenders competing for market share. This makes it harder for small business banking departments to attract and retain customers. |
|
| Lack of trust | Small business owners may be wary of traditional banks due to a perception that they prioritize larger clients and have complex and opaque fee structures. Building trust and transparency with small business customers can be a significant challenge for small business banking departments. |
|
| Limited product offerings | Small business banking departments may have a limited range of products and services compared to their larger counterparts, which can make it difficult to meet the diverse needs of small business owners. This can also limit revenue streams and growth opportunities. |
|
| Limited resources | Small business banking departments often have limited resources compared to larger banks, which can make it difficult to offer competitive products and services, invest in technology, and hire and retain talented staff. |
|
Credit Analysis: key risks and controls
Being in charge of evaluating the creditworthiness of small business loan applications, which includes looking at financial records and cash flow forecasts.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Cash Flow Analysis | For small businesses, cash flow analysis is often more important than collateral or credit history. However, tracking cash flow can be challenging as small business owners may not have a good handle on their cash flow or may have irregular income. |
|
| Compliance Requirements | Commercial banks are subject to a range of compliance requirements when it comes to lending, particularly in areas such as risk management, data privacy, and anti-money laundering. Meeting these requirements can be particularly challenging for small business banking departments, which may lack the resources to devote to compliance activities. |
|
| Limited Information | Small businesses often lack the financial records and reporting systems of larger businesses, making it difficult for banks to gather sufficient information for accurate credit analysis. |
|
| Market Dynamics | The market for small business lending can be volatile and competitive, with new entrants and changing regulations. This can make it challenging for small business banking departments to stay up-to-date with market trends and maintain a competitive edge. |
|
Loan Processing and Underwriting: key risks and controls
Processing loan applications and deciding whether to approve or deny them based on risk and credit analysis.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Incomplete or Inaccurate Applications | Another challenge is incomplete or inaccurate loan applications. Small business owners may not understand the importance of providing complete and accurate information, which can delay the underwriting process. |
|
| Lack of Financial Documentation | One of the biggest challenges for small business loan underwriting is the lack of adequate financial documentation. Small businesses may not have the same level of financial sophistication as larger firms, and may not have the resources to produce the extensive financial documentation required by banks. |
|
Relationship Management: key risks and controls
Developing and maintaining connections with small business clients, including offering direction and financial assistance.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Lack of Personalization | Due to limited resources, small business banking departments may struggle to provide personalized services and attention to their clients. This can lead to a lack of trust and a diminished sense of loyalty on the part of the client. |
|
| Limited Resources | Small business banking departments often have limited resources to dedicate to relationship management activities. They may not have the personnel, time, or budget to invest in building and maintaining strong relationships with their clients. |
|
| Risk Management | Small business banking departments need to manage risk effectively, including credit risk, operational risk, and compliance risk. They must balance the need to support small businesses' growth and profitability with the need to maintain a safe and sound banking environment. Failure to manage risk effectively can result in losses, reputational damage, and harm to client relationships. |
|
| Technology | Small business banking departments must keep up with technological advancements to provide clients with convenient and efficient services. This includes offering online and mobile banking, digital account opening, and other technological solutions that small businesses expect from their banking partners. However, implementing and maintaining technology can be costly and time-consuming, and small business banking departments may struggle to keep pace with larger commercial banks. |
|
Small Business Marketing: key risks and controls
Liable for creating and putting into effect marketing plans to advertise the bank's small business products and services.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Compliance and Regulatory Constraints | Financial institutions are subject to strict regulations and compliance requirements, which can make it challenging to create and implement marketing strategies that meet both the needs of the bank and the requirements of regulatory bodies. |
|
| Lack of Resources | Small business banking departments may not have dedicated marketing teams, leaving employees responsible for marketing tasks on top of their regular duties. |
|
| Limited Digital Presence | Small business banking departments may not have a robust digital presence, making it difficult to reach and engage with their target audience, particularly those who prefer to conduct business online. |
|
| Limited Marketing Budgets | Small business banking departments often have limited marketing budgets, making it difficult to compete with larger financial institutions and their robust marketing campaigns. |
|
| Understanding the Target Market | It's essential for small business banking departments to understand their target market's needs and preferences to create effective marketing strategies that resonate with them. However, this can be challenging as small businesses have diverse needs and preferences. |
|
Small Business Support: key risks and controls
In charge of offering small company clients support, including help setting up accounts, using online banking, and using other banking services.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Access to Funding | Small businesses often face difficulty in accessing funding, which is critical for their growth and expansion. Small business banking departments need to be able to provide easy access to loans and other financial products to meet the funding needs of small businesses. |
|
| Regulatory Compliance | The banking industry is heavily regulated, and small business banking departments need to comply with numerous regulations, which can be challenging and time-consuming. Compliance with regulations related to lending, credit underwriting, and consumer protection adds complexity to the process of providing support to small businesses. |
|
Treasury Management: key risks and controls
Liable for offering treasury and cash management services to small business clients, such as merchant services, cash handling, and payroll processing.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Cash flow management | Managing cash flow is critical for small businesses, but it can be challenging for banks to provide timely and accurate information to help small businesses manage their cash flow. This can result in delayed payments, insufficient funds, or overdrafts, which can impact the financial health of the business. |
|
| Lack of customer awareness | Small businesses may not be aware of the treasury management products and services available to them through their banks. Small business banking departments may need to invest in marketing and education to increase awareness of these offerings. |
|
| Limited product offerings | Small business banking departments may have limited product offerings for treasury management compared to larger banks. This can make it difficult to compete with other banks and fintechs that offer more diverse and innovative treasury management products and services. |
|
| Limited resources | Small business banking departments typically have limited resources to allocate towards treasury management. This can include a lack of staff, technology, or expertise to manage treasury functions effectively. |
|
This register is a starting point for risk identification and benchmarking against international practice. Adapt the risks and controls to your institution's size, products, jurisdiction and regulatory requirements.
Get the Small Business Banking register as an RCSA workbook
A spreadsheet-ready CSV with every risk and control on this page, plus blank columns for control owner, inherent likelihood and impact, control design, operating effectiveness, residual rating and actions. We confirm your email with a 6-digit code, then email you the download link.
Frequently asked questions
What are the key risks in Small Business Banking?
The main risk areas covered are Business Development, Credit Analysis, Loan Processing and Underwriting, Relationship Management, Small Business Marketing, Small Business Support, Treasury Management. Each unit lists its key risks with a short explanation and the best-practice controls that mitigate them.
How do I use this register for a risk and control self-assessment?
Select the risks that apply to your units, map the listed controls to the controls you actually operate, rate inherent risk and control effectiveness, then agree actions for gaps. The free RCSA workbook on this page has the columns ready.
Put these controls to work this month
Start on the cloud risk management software within 24 hours, or ask for training or advice tailored to your institution.