Top risks and controls for Human Resources
The Human Resources register lists 35 key risks and 101 best-practice controls across 7 units: Compensation and Benefits, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, Employee Relations, Human Resources Information Systems (HRIS), Performance Management, Talent Acquisition, Training and Development. Use it to identify risks, benchmark your existing controls or start a risk and control self-assessment (RCSA).
The banking sector is heavily regulated, evolving, and exposed to new hazards every day.
The human resource department is crucial in ensuring that the bank's staff is prepared to manage these risks.
HR can take efforts to reduce risks by conducting risk assessments to identify potential hazards and vulnerabilities in the organization's policies, procedures, and workforce.
HR can assist the bank in maintaining a positive reputation, protecting its assets, and ensuring the security and well-being of its staff and clients by spotting and resolving possible hazards.
Units covered
Compensation and Benefits: key risks and controls
Accountable for creating and managing the bank's perks and pay plans. They might be in charge of creating compensation structures, maintaining employee benefits, and running programmes for incentives and recognition.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Compliance Risk | Commercial banks need to comply with various laws and regulations related to compensation and benefits. Failure to comply with these laws can result in costly fines and legal fees, which can negatively impact the bank's profitability. HR departments should stay up-to-date with changes in regulations and ensure that their compensation and benefits programs are compliant. |
|
| Employee Morale Risk | If the bank's compensation and benefits programs are not perceived as fair and equitable, it can lead to low employee morale and job dissatisfaction. This can result in higher turnover rates and lower productivity, which can negatively impact the bank's overall performance. |
|
| Financial Risk | Compensation and benefits programs can be a significant expense for commercial banks. If the programs are not properly designed or managed, they can result in higher costs than anticipated. HR departments should carefully manage the costs of these programs and ensure that they align with the bank's overall financial goals. |
|
| Reputation Risk | If the bank's compensation and benefits programs are not perceived as fair and competitive, it can harm the bank's reputation. This can lead to difficulty attracting and retaining top talent, which can impact the bank's overall performance. |
|
| Talent Risk | If the bank's compensation and benefits programs are not competitive with those of other banks, it may be difficult to attract and retain top talent. This can lead to a talent shortage, which can impact the bank's ability to grow and compete in the marketplace. |
|
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion: key risks and controls
Accountable for fostering inclusion, equity, and diversity within the bank. They might be in charge of creating guidelines and initiatives to enhance diversity and inclusion, teaching staff members about these topics, and fostering an inclusive culture.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Harassment and Discrimination | HR is responsible for addressing harassment and discrimination complaints. DEI risks can arise if HR fails to take complaints seriously or if there is a lack of trust in the reporting process. This can result in a toxic work environment and can damage the reputation of the organization. |
|
| Performance Management | HR is responsible for monitoring and evaluating employee performance. DEI risks can arise if the evaluation criteria are not fair or if there is a lack of transparency in the evaluation process. This can result in certain groups being unfairly penalized or excluded from opportunities for recognition and promotion. |
|
| Recruitment and Hiring | One of the key functions of HR is to recruit and hire employees. DEI risks can arise if HR fails to attract a diverse pool of candidates or if the selection process is biased towards certain demographics. This can lead to a lack of diversity within the organization and create barriers to opportunities for underrepresented groups. |
|
| Training and Development | HR is also responsible for training and developing employees. DEI risks can arise if training programs are not inclusive or if certain groups are excluded from participation. This can result in an unequal distribution of opportunities for career growth and advancement. |
|
Employee Relations: key risks and controls
Accountable for overseeing ties between the bank and its staff. They might be in charge of handling employee complaints, handling disputes, and fostering a supportive work environment.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Discrimination and harassment | Discrimination and harassment in the workplace can create a hostile work environment, lower employee morale, and lead to legal action against the bank. Banks must have policies and procedures in place to prevent and address these issues, including training and awareness programs for employees and managers. |
|
| Employee fraud | Banks must have strong internal controls and procedures in place to prevent employee fraud, which can result in financial losses, reputational damage, and regulatory fines. |
|
| Employee turnover | High employee turnover can be costly for commercial banks in terms of lost productivity, recruitment and training costs, and reduced morale among remaining employees. It can also indicate poor employee relations, which may further damage the bank's reputation. |
|
| Legal risks | Commercial banks must comply with various federal and state labor laws that govern employment practices, such as equal employment opportunity laws, wage and hour laws, and worker safety laws. Failure to comply with these laws can result in fines, penalties, lawsuits, and damage to the bank's reputation. |
|
| Unionization | Banks that have unionized employees may face additional costs and risks associated with collective bargaining, union negotiations, and potential strikes or work stoppages. |
|
Human Resources Information Systems (HRIS): key risks and controls
Is in charge of overseeing the bank's HRIS, the platform for managing employee data and HR procedures. They might be in charge of keeping personnel data, customising the HRIS, and assisting users.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Compliance Risks | Commercial banks are subject to strict legal and regulatory compliance requirements. HRIS systems must comply with these regulations such as Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) requirements, employee privacy laws, and data protection regulations. Non-compliance can result in penalties, fines, or legal action. |
|
| Data Security Risks | HRIS systems store sensitive employee data such as social security numbers, bank account details, and personal identification information. Commercial banks are at high risk of cyber-attacks due to the sensitive financial data they handle. A breach in HRIS can lead to significant reputational and financial loss. |
|
| Integration Risks | Integration risks arise when HRIS systems do not integrate well with other internal systems such as payroll, accounting, or performance management systems. This can cause inconsistencies in data and disrupt the smooth functioning of the bank's HR operations. |
|
| Technical Risks | HRIS software and systems require technical expertise to manage and operate. Technical risks may arise from system failures, data corruption, or software bugs. These risks can cause delays, loss of productivity, and can have a significant impact on the bank's human resources functions. |
|
| User Error Risks | HRIS systems are only as good as the data that is inputted into them. User errors such as incorrect data entry, lack of proper training, or misuse of the system can lead to inaccurate data, causing operational problems and decision-making issues. |
|
Performance Management: key risks and controls
The performance management programme for the bank must be developed and implemented. They might be in charge of assigning performance objectives, carrying out performance reviews, and giving staff members feedback and coaching.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Bias and Discrimination | Performance management systems that are not designed to be fair and unbiased can create significant legal risks for commercial banks. If employees feel that they are being discriminated against based on their race, gender, or other protected characteristics, the bank could face legal action. |
|
| Compliance Risks | Banks are subject to numerous regulations and laws, and performance management systems must comply with these rules. If a bank's performance management system does not meet regulatory requirements, the bank could face legal consequences and financial penalties. |
|
| Employee Turnover | Poorly designed performance management systems can lead to high employee turnover rates. If employees feel that they are not being fairly assessed or that their contributions are not being recognized, they may leave the bank for a more favorable work environment. |
|
| Inaccurate Performance Evaluations | Performance management systems that rely on subjective evaluations rather than objective measures can be inaccurate and unreliable. This can lead to ineffective decision-making, such as promotions or terminations based on faulty assessments. |
|
| Lack of Transparency | A lack of transparency in the performance management process can lead to mistrust and confusion among employees. If employees do not understand how their performance is being evaluated or how their performance impacts their career progression, they may become disengaged and resentful. |
|
| Reputation Risks | Poor performance management practices can damage a bank's reputation. If employees feel that the performance management system is unfair or biased, they may become demotivated, disengaged, and even spread negative word-of-mouth about the bank's culture and practices. |
|
Talent Acquisition: key risks and controls
Accountable for luring in, locating, and hiring the best personnel for the bank. They might be in charge of creating job descriptions, finding applicants, reviewing resumes, holding interviews, and extending employment offers.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Compliance risk | Banks need to comply with various regulations and laws related to talent acquisition, such as equal employment opportunity laws, immigration laws, and data privacy laws. Failure to comply with these regulations can result in legal and financial penalties, as well as reputational damage. |
|
| Cost risk | Talent acquisition can be expensive, especially if the bank is competing for top talent. Recruitment costs, relocation expenses, and signing bonuses can add up quickly and strain the bank's finances. |
|
| Reputation risk | The reputation of a bank is closely linked to the quality of its workforce. Poor hiring decisions or talent acquisition processes can result in negative publicity, which can damage the bank's reputation. |
|
| Talent shortage risk | The banking industry is highly competitive, and attracting and retaining top talent can be a significant challenge. Banks may face a shortage of skilled workers in certain areas, which can lead to a lack of capacity or capability to deliver key business objectives. |
|
| Turnover risk | High turnover rates can be costly for banks, as they need to invest time and resources in recruiting, training, and onboarding new employees. High turnover can also lead to lower employee morale, reduced productivity, and loss of institutional knowledge. |
|
Training and Development: key risks and controls
Responsible for creating and delivering training programmes to assist employees in developing their abilities. They might be in charge of creating training materials, conducting training sessions, and determining how well training programmes are working.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Compliance | Banks operate in a highly regulated environment, and there is a risk that training and development programs may not be compliant with regulations. Banks must ensure that their training and development programs comply with all relevant laws and regulations. |
|
| Cost | One of the primary risks associated with training and development is the cost of implementing such programs. Training and development programs can be expensive, and banks may not see a return on investment (ROI) immediately. Therefore, banks must carefully consider the cost-benefit analysis before implementing any training and development programs. |
|
| Effectiveness | There is a risk that training and development programs may not be effective in achieving their intended outcomes. Banks must ensure that their training and development programs are designed and implemented in a way that maximizes their effectiveness. |
|
| Employee retention | There is a risk that the investment made in training and development may not pay off if employees leave the bank soon after completing their training. This can be costly to the bank as they would have to invest in training new employees. |
|
| Time | Training and development programs require time and resources to be effective. Banks may have to sacrifice productivity and revenue in the short-term to accommodate the time spent on training and development. Therefore, banks must be strategic in their approach to training and development to minimize any negative impact on operations. |
|
This register is a starting point for risk identification and benchmarking against international practice. Adapt the risks and controls to your institution's size, products, jurisdiction and regulatory requirements.
Get the Human Resources register as an RCSA workbook
A spreadsheet-ready CSV with every risk and control on this page, plus blank columns for control owner, inherent likelihood and impact, control design, operating effectiveness, residual rating and actions. We confirm your email with a 6-digit code, then email you the download link.
Frequently asked questions
What are the key risks in Human Resources?
The main risk areas covered are Compensation and Benefits, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, Employee Relations, Human Resources Information Systems (HRIS), Performance Management, Talent Acquisition, Training and Development. Each unit lists its key risks with a short explanation and the best-practice controls that mitigate them.
How do I use this register for a risk and control self-assessment?
Select the risks that apply to your units, map the listed controls to the controls you actually operate, rate inherent risk and control effectiveness, then agree actions for gaps. The free RCSA workbook on this page has the columns ready.
Put these controls to work this month
Start on the cloud risk management software within 24 hours, or ask for training or advice tailored to your institution.