Top risks and controls for Audit
The Audit register lists 38 key risks and 195 best-practice controls across 6 units: Compliance Audit, Financial Audit, Fraud Audit, Information Technology Audit, Internal Audit, Operational Audit. Use it to identify risks, benchmark your existing controls or start a risk and control self-assessment (RCSA).
An integral part of the banking sector, the audit function is responsible for confirming that a bank's activities adhere to applicable rules and regulations and that its financial statements are reliable and accurate.
The banking sector has grown more sophisticated recently, and new dangers are constantly arising. As a result, performing risk assessments has grown to be an essential part of the audit function at banks.
Auditor risk assessments allow them to discover potential risks and weaknesses in a bank's operations, allowing them to focus their auditing efforts and offer useful management advice on how to reduce those risks.
As a result, banks are better able to uphold their good name, safeguard the assets of their clients, and meet regulatory requirements.
Units covered
Compliance Audit: key risks and controls
Accountable for making sure the bank abides by all relevant rules and regulations. Usually, the compliance audit team checks the bank's policies and practices to make sure they comply with legal standards.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Complex Regulations | Commercial banks are subject to a wide range of regulations, which can be complex and challenging to navigate. Compliance auditors must have a deep understanding of these regulations to ensure that the bank is operating in compliance with them. |
|
| Cultural and Organizational Challenges | Compliance auditors may face challenges related to the bank's culture and organizational structure. Some employees may not fully understand the importance of compliance, or may be resistant to change. Compliance auditors must work closely with the bank's management team to address these challenges and ensure that the bank's compliance program is effective. |
|
| Data Management | Banks collect and store a large amount of data, which must be properly managed to ensure compliance with regulations. Compliance auditors must have a thorough understanding of the data management systems used by the bank and the regulations that govern data management. |
|
| Human Resource Management | Compliance audit is heavily dependent on human resources. Getting the right person with appropriate qualifications, experience and technical knowledge of the compliance standards is a challenge. |
|
| Internal Controls | Compliance auditors must review and test the bank's internal controls to ensure that they are operating effectively. This can be a time-consuming process, and auditors must be thorough to ensure that all areas of the bank's operations are covered. |
|
| IT Infrastructure | With advancements in technology, auditors must continuously update themselves with the latest technologies, tools and techniques for carrying out audits. However, in some banks, the IT infrastructure may not be well equipped to handle such new technological advancements, which becomes a challenge for compliance audit. |
|
| Rapidly Changing Regulations | Regulations in the banking industry are constantly changing, and compliance auditors must stay up-to-date with these changes. This requires a continuous learning process and a high level of flexibility to adapt to new regulations. |
|
Financial Audit: key risks and controls
Accountable for checking that the bank's financial statements are correct, comprehensive, and compliant with all applicable accounting standards. The bank's financial records, transactions, and reports are normally examined by the financial audit team.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Complexity of financial products | Commercial banks offer a range of financial products, such as loans, mortgages, credit cards, and investments. These products can be complex, and the financial statements may contain a significant amount of data, making it difficult for auditors to ensure accuracy. |
|
| Cybersecurity risk | As banks become more digital, the risk of cybersecurity breaches increases. Auditors must ensure that the bank has appropriate cybersecurity measures in place and that they are effective in protecting the bank's assets and data. |
|
| Data quality and availability | Auditors must rely on data provided by the bank to perform their audits. If the data is incomplete, inaccurate, or not available, it can be challenging to conduct an accurate audit. |
|
| Fraud risk | Commercial banks are at risk of fraud, including internal fraud by employees and external fraud by customers or other third parties. Auditors must be aware of these risks and ensure that appropriate controls are in place to mitigate them. |
|
| Regulatory compliance | Commercial banks are highly regulated, and auditors must ensure that the bank is in compliance with all relevant laws and regulations. This requires a thorough understanding of the regulatory environment, including changes in laws and regulations, and staying up to date with the latest changes. |
|
| Time pressure | Auditors must complete their work within a limited timeframe, which can be challenging in a complex and dynamic environment like a commercial bank. |
|
Fraud Audit: key risks and controls
Accountable for identifying and looking into cases of theft, fraud, and other financial crimes. To make sure that fraud risks are identified and addressed, the unit closely collaborates with the internal audit and compliance functions.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Complexity of Banking Operations | Commercial banks have complex operations, and identifying fraudulent transactions can be difficult, especially in large banks with a vast customer base. |
|
| Insider Threats | Fraud can also be committed by insiders, such as employees or managers, who have access to sensitive information and can manipulate transactions. Detecting insider fraud can be challenging as they may have a deeper understanding of the bank's operations and systems. |
|
| Lack of Adequate Resources | Fraud audits require significant resources, including skilled personnel, technology, and time. Limited resources can hamper the effectiveness of fraud audits in commercial banks. |
|
| Large Volume of Transactions | Commercial banks handle a large volume of transactions daily, making it challenging to identify fraudulent transactions within the vast amount of data. |
|
| Legal and Regulatory Compliance | Fraud audits in commercial banks must comply with various legal and regulatory requirements, such as the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA), Anti-Money Laundering (AML), and the USA PATRIOT Act. Non-compliance can result in severe penalties. |
|
| Sophisticated Fraud Techniques | Fraudsters use sophisticated techniques to conceal their activities, such as identity theft, phishing, and social engineering, making it difficult to detect fraudulent transactions. |
|
Information Technology Audit: key risks and controls
Responsible for checking that the bank's information technology systems, including networks, hardware, and software, are safe, dependable, and adhere to all relevant rules and regulations.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Complexity of the IT environment | Commercial banks typically have complex IT systems that are often distributed across multiple locations, making it difficult to conduct a comprehensive audit. |
|
| Data protection | Commercial banks hold sensitive customer data that needs to be protected during the IT audit process. |
|
| Limited access to information | The IT department of a commercial bank may not always be willing to provide unrestricted access to systems and data, which can hinder the effectiveness of the IT audit. |
|
| Regulatory compliance | Commercial banks operate in a highly regulated environment, and IT audits need to ensure that the bank's IT systems are compliant with all relevant regulations. |
|
| Risk management | Banks are exposed to various risks such as cybersecurity, fraud, and operational risks, which must be considered during an IT audit. |
|
| Staff expertise | IT auditors need to have a deep understanding of both banking operations and IT systems to effectively assess the risks and controls in place. |
|
| Time constraints | IT audits in commercial banks are often conducted within tight timelines, making it challenging to conduct a comprehensive audit. |
|
Internal Audit: key risks and controls
Is in charge of examining and evaluating the internal controls, risk management procedures, and financial reporting of the bank. The internal audit team is also in charge of locating weak points and recommending enhancements to management.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Complex Operations | Commercial banks have complex operations, which can make it difficult to identify and evaluate risks. Internal auditors must have a good understanding of the bank's operations and be able to assess the risks associated with each area of the business. |
|
| Conflicts of Interest | Internal auditors must remain independent and objective in their work, which can be challenging in a commercial bank where there may be conflicts of interest. For example, auditors may be asked to evaluate the work of their colleagues or managers, which can create tensions and challenges. |
|
| Data Analysis | Banks generate a vast amount of data, and internal auditors must be able to analyze and interpret this data to identify potential risks and control weaknesses. This requires strong analytical skills and the ability to work with complex data sets. |
|
| Human Resource Management | Internal auditors must also be able to evaluate the performance of bank employees. This can be challenging when they have to interact with individuals who may not be receptive to criticism or feedback. |
|
| IT Security | As banks increasingly rely on technology to conduct their operations, IT security has become a critical area of focus for internal auditors. They must have a good understanding of the bank's IT systems and be able to assess the risks associated with them. |
|
| Regulatory Compliance | Banks operate in a highly regulated environment, and internal auditors must ensure that the bank complies with all relevant laws and regulations. This requires a deep understanding of regulatory requirements and the ability to stay up-to-date with changes in regulations. |
|
Operational Audit: key risks and controls
Accountable for assessing the effectiveness and efficiency of the operational procedures at the bank. In order to find opportunities for improvement, the operational audit team often evaluates the bank's processes, systems, and procedures.
| Risk | What can go wrong | Best-practice controls |
|---|---|---|
| Complexity of Banking Operations | Commercial banks have complex and diversified operations that involve various departments and processes. Conducting operational audits in such an environment requires auditors to have a comprehensive understanding of the bank's operations and processes, including risk management, credit analysis, compliance, and regulatory requirements. |
|
| Data and Technology Challenges | Commercial banks store vast amounts of data and use complex technology systems to manage their operations. Auditors must have the necessary expertise to access and analyze this data, understand the technology systems, and identify any potential issues or risks associated with the bank's technology and data management processes. |
|
| Regulatory Compliance | Commercial banks operate under strict regulatory requirements and guidelines, which can pose a challenge for auditors. Auditors need to ensure that the bank's operations comply with all applicable regulations and guidelines, such as the Federal Reserve Board, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, and Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. |
|
| Resistance to Change | Commercial banks have established practices and procedures that may not align with recommended audit practices or may resist changing their current processes. Auditors may face resistance from bank staff, which can make it challenging to implement recommendations or changes suggested during the audit. |
|
| Staffing and Resource Constraints | Conducting operational audits in a commercial bank can require a significant amount of resources, including personnel, time, and financial resources. The availability of resources can be a challenge for audit teams, especially when conducting audits in large banks or during times of economic uncertainty. |
|
| Time Constraints | Commercial banks operate in a fast-paced environment, and auditors must complete their work within tight deadlines. This can be a challenge, especially when conducting comprehensive audits that involve multiple departments and processes. |
|
This register is a starting point for risk identification and benchmarking against international practice. Adapt the risks and controls to your institution's size, products, jurisdiction and regulatory requirements.
Get the Audit register as an RCSA workbook
A spreadsheet-ready CSV with every risk and control on this page, plus blank columns for control owner, inherent likelihood and impact, control design, operating effectiveness, residual rating and actions. We confirm your email with a 6-digit code, then email you the download link.
Frequently asked questions
What are the key risks in Audit?
The main risk areas covered are Compliance Audit, Financial Audit, Fraud Audit, Information Technology Audit, Internal Audit, Operational Audit. Each unit lists its key risks with a short explanation and the best-practice controls that mitigate them.
How do I use this register for a risk and control self-assessment?
Select the risks that apply to your units, map the listed controls to the controls you actually operate, rate inherent risk and control effectiveness, then agree actions for gaps. The free RCSA workbook on this page has the columns ready.
Put these controls to work this month
Start on the cloud risk management software within 24 hours, or ask for training or advice tailored to your institution.